Share this page
Pin It

2011-2012

Toning Pants—Too Good to Be True?

 

By Alexa Kleingartner, M.S., John P. Porcari, Ph.D., Scott Doberstein, M.S., Charles Hendrix, M.S., and Carl Foster, Ph.D.

“Achieve amazing in half the time.”

That’s the promise Fila USATM is using to sell its Toning Resistance Tight Capri, a $50 exercise pant for women with compression toning panels that, it is claimed, “streamline the figure,” while purportedly increasing the efficiency of a wearer’s workout. The hangtag marketed with these polyester and Lycra-fabric capris claims a “50% increase in muscle workouts” and “41% more support.” And a press release from Fila states that the capris are “designed to increase muscle exercise, which improves the efficiency as well as recovery of an existing workout.” 

Fila’s claims caught the attention of the Workout Watchdog® at the American Council on Exercise (ACE). So earlier this year, ACE enlisted a team of exercise scientists from the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse to test the Toning Resistance Tight Capris and evaluate the claims made for them. An underlying assumption for the study was that if the Fila capris did, in fact, increase muscle activation, then there would be a corresponding increase in the caloric expenditure of the wearer and an improvement in her muscle tone.

The Study

Led by John Porcari, Ph.D., and Alexa Kleingartner, M.S., researchers from the University’s Departments of Exercise and Sport Science and Physical Therapy first recruited 16 healthy female volunteers between the ages of 18 and 24 years. Prior to actual testing, each subject was fitted with a pair of Fila Toning Resistance Tight Capris.

During testing, the subjects walked on a level treadmill at 2.5 mph, 3.0 mph and 3.5 mph for five minutes at each speed. This sequence was repeated twice; once while wearing the toning capris and once while wearing regular athletic shorts. The order was chosen at random and each subject was given five minutes of rest between sequences. 

Meanwhile, researchers continuously monitored each subject’s VO2 and heart rate (HR), as well as ratings of perceived exertion (RPE), which were determined every five minutes (after each stage). Muscle activity was also measured with EMG in the gluteus maximus, biceps femoris and vastus lateralis for 15 seconds at the end of each five-minute stage. 

The Results

After analyzing the data, the researchers found that there was a 2-percent increase in VO2, plus a small boost in caloric expenditure (0.09 more kcal/min) while exercising in the toning capris versus conventional athletic shorts. Researchers found no significant differences in HR. As for RPE, subjects reported significantly higher ratings of exertion while wearing the toning capris, especially during the 3.0 mph trial (Table 1). When comparing muscle activation by EMG, researchers found no significant differences during any of the trials attributable to the wearing of toning capris (Table 2). 

Subjects were also asked to write down what they felt while wearing the toning capris compared to the athletic shorts, and several stated that they felt increased compression and resistance around the hip joint, which made it more difficult to walk. 

The Bottom Line

Although the research showed a slight increase in calorie burn while wearing Fila’s toning capris, in a real-world scenario that boost would be negligible. 

“Calorie-wise, it’s like burning off the equivalent of half a single Peanut M&M,” says John Porcari, Ph.D. “You would be better off walking an extra 50 yards than wearing these capris to achieve that benefit.” 

In response to the claims of a 50-percent increase in muscle workouts, the researchers reported that the Fila capris didn’t deliver there either. 

“These pants have toning panels, which provide resistance, except your butt muscles and quads and hamstrings are so strong that putting a little bit of elastic in there doesn’t add much resistance,” Porcari says. “In order to provide enough resistance to be beneficial, the pants would have to be so restrictive that you wouldn’t be able to easily move. To achieve a 50-percent increase in muscle activation, you’d have to be wearing something akin to a straight jacket.” 

As for “achieving amazing in half the time,” researchers point to the old adage: “If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.” That said, for some women the look and fit of these capris may deliver psychological benefits that can’t be quantified. 

“I would say that these toning capris are similar to other compression pants that you can buy,” says Alexa Kleingartner, M.S. “I wouldn’t recommend buying them to make a difference in the effectiveness of your workout, but the extra compression and tightness may give you a butt lift and a better shape. That factor is definitely there—so if you think you look better, you may be more willing to work out. And that’s always a good thing.”

Table 1. Physiological Responses to Wearing Athletic Shorts and Toning Capris (N=16).
 

Athletic Shorts 

Mean ± SD

Toning Capris

Mean ± SD

Heart Rate (bpm)

   2.5 mph

   3.0 mph

   3.5 mph

 

99 ± 10.0

105 ± 10.9

115 ± 11.9

 

99 ± 10.9

106 ± 11.1

115 ± 11.9

VO2 (mL/kg/min)

   2.5 mph

   3.0 mph

   3.5 mph

 

12.7 ± 0.83

14.7 ± 0.93

 17.5 ± 1.10

 

 13.2 ± 0.96*

15.0 ± 0.89

17.6 ± 1.10

kcals/min

   2.5 mph

   3.0 mph

   3.5 mph 

 

3.88 ± 0.437

4.48 ± 0.483

5.34 ± 0.486

 

4.02 ± 0.399*

4.58 ± 0.410

5.37 ± 0.480

RPE

   2.5 mph

   3.0 mph

   3.5 mph

 

 7.4 ± 0.62

8.6 ± 1.02

10.4 ± 1.31

 

7.7 ± 0.79

9.1 ± 1.15*

10.7 ± 1.40

*Significantly greater than athletic shorts (p< .05)
Table 2. Muscle Activation (% MVIC) of the Gluteus Maximus, Biceps Femoris and Vastus Lateralis While Wearing Athletic Shorts and Toning Capris 
 

Athletic Shorts 

Mean ± SD

Toning Capris

Mean ± SD

Gluteus Maximus (N=16)

   2.5 mph

   3.0 mph

   3.5 mph

 

 34 ± 27.3

32 ± 19.9

34 ± 19.5

 

28 ± 16.4

30 ± 17.3

32 ± 17.7

Biceps Femoris (N=15)

   2.5 mph

   3.0 mph

   3.5 mph

 

19 ± 13.1

21 ± 12.7

 24 ± 13.5

 

 18 ± 10.5

21 ± 12.3

24 ± 12.5

Vastus Lateralis (N=13)

   2.5 mph

   3.0 mph

   3.5 mph 

 

26 ± 8.7

32 ± 9.7

39 ± 10.2

 

27 ± 9.8

32 ± 10.4

39 ± 12.1 


Search This Issue
Keeping You Posted

What Studies Do You Think We Should Sponsor?

As we look forward to 2013, ACE will be significantly expanding its research efforts to include even more studies. That’s where your expertise and experience comes in. We’d like to know what you would like to see studied—what products, techniques and trends do you and your clients have questions about? Please email your ideas to research@ACEfitness.org.
Read More »

ACE Introduces New CEC Opportunity: The Best of ACE Certified News

We are always on the lookout for new ways to make it easier for you to access the education you need. This year, we are introducing our new “Best of ACE Certified News” series, which will bring together the most popular and relevant topics from the past year or so. Upcoming issues will highlight several hot topics. For this, our first issue, we’ve brought together the most popular ACE-sponsored research studies of 2011 and 2012.
Read More »

Sign-up Today

Sign-up to receive Certified News, ACE's free monthly certified professionals e-newsletter.

Ace Certified News

ACE's Certified News is produced 12 times per year by the American Council on Exercise. No material may be reprinted without permission.

Publisher: Scott Goudeseune
Technical Editor: Cedric X. Bryant, Ph.D.
Editor In Chief: Christine J. Ekeroth
Art Director: Karen F. McGuire