August 24, 2011
Selecting the right exercise equipment is important for comfort and function, and it can enhance the overall workout experience.
Similar to selecting running shoes or a bicycle helmet, the best headphones for one person might be a poor choice for another. Important factors to consider when selecting headphones include fit, acoustics, portability, compatibility with your music player, and if they stay on while you are exercising. However, the most important question to answer before purchasing headphones to wear during exercise is, “will it be safe to wear headphones where you are going to exercise?” If you are exercising outdoors, the answer will often be “no.” Let me elaborate:
A few weeks ago, I was running trails in a canyon that is known for its steep rocky terrain and wildlife that includes many birds, big jackrabbits, coyotes, and rattlesnakes. Yes, rattlesnakes! Because I know that I might come across a rattlesnake, I pay very close attention while running or mountain biking there. Unfortunately, I cannot say the same for the other three people I saw on the trails that day.
The first was a man wearing headphones while running down a steep, twisty, rocky descent. Even though my feet made plenty of noise running down the hill as I caught up to him, the man did not hear me until I was only two steps behind him. Startled, he literally jumped a few feet to his left to get out of my way. Luckily, he did not land poorly or injure himself on the rocks.
The other two people I came across during that trail run were women wearing headphones—one walking solo and the other running solo. This might seem perfectly normal to some people; however, here are some good reasons why they would have been better off without the headphones:
- Safety. When you listen to music through headphones, you muffle the ambient noises around you. This can prevent you from hearing people or cars approaching until they are very close to you, leaving less time for you to respond to avoid a collision or worse.
- Nature. Isn’t experiencing nature one of the main reasons for outdoor running or hiking? These three individuals missed out on hearing the birds, animals, and the wind on that day.
- Snakes. On that particular day, I was running along a narrow singletrack trail when I heard a snake slithering through the tall grass about 1.5 feet to my right. I jumped straight up in the air and to the left as I looked down to see if there was a rattle. Luckily, it was only a king snake, so it turned out to be just an exciting wildlife encounter.
These are just three examples from one trail run that I did on my lunch hour, but they illustrate some of the key reasons why headphones may not be appropriate for all exercise outdoors.
Music has been shown to be motivational for people during exercise, so the desire to wear headphones during exercise outdoors is understandable. Before you do, be sure to determine if the area where you will be exercising outdoors is safe for wearing headphones. If not, you are better off leaving them at home and enjoying the sounds of nature or the city. It could be the difference between hearing a person, car, or even a snake early enough to avoid a collision or worse.
Todd Galati, M.A.Contributor
Todd Galati holds a master’s degree in kinesiology, a bachelor’s degree in athletic training, and all four ACE certifications. Galati’s experience includes directing youth fitness programs focused on reducing obesity, cardiovascular disease, and type 2 diabetes at the UC San Diego School of Medicine, teaching courses in biomechanics, applied kinesiology, and anatomy at Cal State San Marcos and San Diego State University, conducting human performance studies as a research physiologist with the U.S. Navy, personal training in medical, nonprofit, and commercial facilities, and coaching endurance athletes to state and national championships and other goals once felt to be out of reach.Full Bio Todd Galati »