• Search ACE
  • Live Help
  • (888) 825-3636

December 9, 2011, 09:55AM PT in Fitness Trends Blog  |  32 Comments

Fitness Professionals Outraged By Viral Video From a Crossfit Gym

Watch the video below of individuals attempting the "continental clean and jerk" at a Crossfit gym, and you will know why it has gone viral among fitness professionals and strength and conditioning coaches:

 

Even if you are not a trained strength and conditioning coach or fitness professional, it's hard to avoid cringing in fear that someone is going to injure themselves.

And that's exactly why this video has gone viral and caused outrage throughout the fitness professional community.

ACE's Fitness Expert & Exercise Physiologist, Pete McCall, said this video "is not an indictment against Crossfit, but a reminder of why it's important to emphasize good form when learning and performing challenging exercises."

And it's the trainer's obligation to teach the fundamentals — from basic movement forms to progressing to the advanced movement. "When starting an exercise program, learning proper form and movement skill is fundamental before progressing in intensity," McCall said.

Obviously, the coaches of the individuals in the particular video above did not take the time to teach their clients proper skill. McCall said this is particularly concerning and that without the fundamentals, "the participants WILL get injured."

Speaking to the same video, Michael Boyle of StrengthCoach.com lists "we will do no harm" as the first item of a manifesto for strength coaches. Boyle writes, "athletes and clients trust [their strength coaches and personal trainers] to make decisions for them," so it's important to ensure they are safe and know their limits.

If you're looking to work with a strength coach or personal trainer, how do you know they are the type of professional who will take the time to show you the fundamentals so that you won't end up in the next viral YouTube video?

"If a trainer demonstrates a technically challenging exercise that you don’t feel comfortable attempting your next exercise, run (not walk) away from that trainer in order to avoid an unnecessary (and completely preventable) injury," McCall said.

Always make sure to ask, understand and practice the basic movement before progressing to the more challenging movement. As great as it would be to tell brag to friends and family that you completed a difficult continental clean and jerk, wouldn't it be better to be able to say you did it with proper form and without injuring yourself? Master the basics first.

By the American Council on Exercise

Comments

Commenting has closed for this post

By Laura Folsom, Friday, December 09, 2011
Cringe is right, actually I had to cover my eyes it was so painful to watch. A perfect example of what NOT to do. I feel embarrassed for the trainers. What were they thinking???????????

By Tamara McCollough, Friday, December 09, 2011
Terrible, terrible, terrible!

By Jacques Courseault, Friday, December 09, 2011
Clearly they are using plastic weights... C'mon...

[+] Replies

By Alexander Barbaretta, Monday, December 12, 2011
Regardless of plastic weights, their form was terrible and apparently were not being supervised very well. And it may be light plastic weight but they still seem to be struggling, which says they aren't strong enough to handle the weight with proper form.

By John Gaeta, Monday, December 12, 2011
I would suggest using less weight to learn the form.....Although this is a cross fit gym, all cross fit facilities do not do this. Good example of what not to do as a fitness professional.

By Kevin Schmitt, Monday, December 12, 2011
I run a CrossFit facility and techniques like this would not be tolerated. Yes, using an axle instead of a bar provides more of a challenge, but if it cause an athlete to perform a lift in an unsafe manor than it is not worth it. Safety is first. I expect my athletes to show competence in movements before I allow them to perform any other advanced lifts.

By Abigail Zenner, Monday, December 12, 2011
I took a Crossfit fundamentals class once and we all had to use PVC pipe before even moving onto a metal bar. The weight they're trying to lift is much to heavy and the trainers didn't even adjust it from person to person. What were they thinking? My back aches watching that.

By Elizabeth Weide, Monday, December 12, 2011
Wow... I can't believe what they are doing. I've been doing CrossFit for 7 months now and am surprised that gym is allowing horrible form. My coach's biggest thing is perfecting form; if your form is bad, you're going to hurt yourself. I've never seen anything like that at my CrossFit gym. Not acceptable. Wow...

By Sandra Rikkers, Monday, December 12, 2011
They didn't even give pointers except that one guy kept saying "Get lower" geez, back and knee buckling!

By Kris Cameron, Monday, December 12, 2011
I couldn't finish watching this! It was like watching a multiple car accident!

By Mark Zaragoza, Monday, December 12, 2011
You can cringe and close your eyes all you want. Yes this is a poor excuse for a Crossfit Trainer that I have ever seen, but I will tell you this. I can go into any Baily's, Gold's, or any other gym and video the improper form or use of equipment of it's clients. All while the Certified Strengthening specialist is sitting there talking to someone they are more interested in instead of their clients. As a Crossfit Trainer we are thought (M.C.I.)MOVEMENT(Master it), CONSISTENCY(continually show mastering of movement, and consistently show to WODs), INTENSITY(Only after showing you own the move, as to not provoke injury). I am appalled that this would be posted on ACE, but not surprised. Sorry that Crossfit is showing the world that results can happen, without the use of a slushy bar in the gym, but with actual sweat, and tears. I just lost a lot of respect for the fitness community at labeling this as all Crossfit Boxes, this is just one... AND A POOR ONE

[+] Replies

By Tina Thumm, Monday, December 12, 2011
"ACE's Fitness Expert & Exercise Physiologist, Pete McCall, said this video "is not an indictment against Crossfit, but a reminder of why it's important to emphasize good form when learning and performing challenging exercises." Way to read the entire article before posting your reaction.  As indicated by the above quote, the message here isn't "Crossfit is bad."  The message is that not all Crossfit gyms and instructors are created equal; you should look for a Crossfit gym that has competent, well-educated, safety-minded instructors.  Just as you should for any other type of gym or exercise instructor/personal trainer.  ACE posts these kinds of messages about all kinds of things in the fitness industry.  If anything, they are putting things in perspective for people who are not familiar with Crossfit and may get a bad impression of it from the video, which was already viral when it came to ACE's attention. 

[+] Replies

By Tim Weeks, Tuesday, December 13, 2011
Making excuses for and defending this is absurd and they should have their liscence pulled as well as you.

By Kimberly Coseglia, Monday, December 12, 2011
No, seriously? Is this for real? I think it mist be a hole, because.this is so scared bad that it doesn't even seem like it could possibly be real...that people.would really DO this, or that so called trainers would actually allow people to do this. Nahhhh, it just can't be for real. Can it?

[+] Replies

By La Tricia Haymon, Monday, December 12, 2011
Wow!!!  That was scary. 

By Will Richardson, Tuesday, December 13, 2011
These comments show how stupid people are.. This video is showing the axel clean & press with a powerlifters technique.... To all the people with negative comments, get your facts straight before you start ragging on something you know nothing about. Its people like you that give CrossFit a bad name

[+] Replies

By Will Richardson, Tuesday, December 13, 2011
axle**

By Kelly Lamb, Tuesday, December 13, 2011
At the beginning of the article, ACE prefaces the video content by mentioning the Continental Clean and Jerk contest. Have any of you ever seen a Strongman contest? This is a technique that strongmen have used for centuries. I'm not saying its right for "normal" fitness-minded people, esp. without weight belts, but it is a recognized movement of a sport. Watch the strongman in this video - he uses the same techniques: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8v8ScjtYRZA&feature=related This is mild to some of the strongman events that require tossing the weight up overhead! Speaking to CrossFit - just one video is a terrible representation of what CrossFit really is. Proper clean and jerking technique is taught first with PVC, then light bars, then eventually bumper plates (that's what those rubber plates are called and they are used quite a bit in Olympic lifting). In addition to Olympic lifting techniques, other fitness skills are taught, such as gymnastics, plyometrics, endurance, mobility, etc. It's a very well-rounded way of training, but intense and definitely not for everyone. Just wanted to throw a little info out there on CrossFit and strongman lifting. When I saw the video, I also cringed and wondered why the normal fitness-minded CrossFit population would want to participate in a strongman competition. It's definitely not a competition I would endorse for the CrossFit (or any other) clientele.

By Carlos Echandy, Tuesday, December 13, 2011
I find it appalling that somebody that knows nothing about next level Olympic Weightlifting training can actually give their opinion here and assassinate the character of the training that goes on at Albany Crossfit, one of the best affiliates running in the East Coast. In case you did not notice…what is going on in this video is non other than wider than normal barbell lift training. Once you go fat you will never go back! We all know it's not about the length, but the thickness. These bars are great for variation and will give your grip a boost. The fat bar is a classic grip-training tool used by competitive strongmen.Here is the link of Kurtis Bowler (owner and founder of Rainier CrossFit) instructing a female athlete in the somewhat unusual techniques required to get a fat bar from the ground to overhead. Breaking the movement down into pieces, Bowler demonstrates the difficulty of getting the bar into the rack position, noting that his fingers can’t even fully close around the thick 2-inch-diameter bar. “It just wants to shoot out of the bottom of your hands,” he explains. Bowler wraps up the session with an attempt at a new PR: 233 lb. from floor to overhead. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WBMx82NxqN4&feature=results_main&playnext=1&list=PLB14295FE76D11F2C I travel all over the US and train at different facilities. During my visit at Albany Crossfit (I’ve been there 3-4 times in the past 4 years) I received great training and endure some of the toughest workouts I’ve ever been exposed to…the rest of the time, you can find me training at Tamalpais Crossfit, Ross Valley Crossfit and/or Crossfit Marin in Northern California. Carlos Echandy, Level 1 Certified Coach

[+] Replies

By Tim Weeks, Tuesday, December 13, 2011
I was on the Air Force All PACAF power lifting team in the eighties, lifting most of my life and never saw such terrible technique.  Without a belt, if they try that with any weight they will hurt thier backs.  You are a fool.

By Vikrant Parekar, Tuesday, December 13, 2011
ITS TERRIBLE AND UNBELIEVABLE TO BELIEVE THAT THIS STUFF IS HAPPENING IN U.S.A

By Allyson Shumate, Tuesday, December 13, 2011
are these certified trainers? Please say it isn't so!

By TEWANA JOHNSON, Tuesday, December 13, 2011
That is why we as professional with exercise science degrees need to take a stand and become license. We need a national exam to be registered as fitness professionals . . . period. You have RN's & RD's who can not practice unless they take a national exam. Anyone can take a three day or two day course and say am a personal trainer, fitness coach, wellness specialist. Please . . . . get an understanding of how the human body work and you can not do that in three days. Try three years with a bacholar degree. The human body can not go through that much stress. Someone is going to die, someone important and then it will be too late. As professional we need to take a stand. Everyone is out to make money it not about helping people, or form, or losing healthy weight. Oh!!!!!!! can I add as one of the fitness pioneer (ACE) , along with ACSM and AFAA we need to be license and looked at a professional. Not a joke. Like this video. You have the power, to license us. One national exam, you just dont want to do it because you will be losing money. It cost $365 to take a certification test to become personal trainer. $259 to become a group fitness instuctor. Just think everyone what to be a personal trainer and charge people $45 to $100 and hour. Who has no education (sometime) behind trainer clients that are overweight, has diabetes, and a phase 3 cardiac patient. Education is the key. Bacholar degrees in exercise science, Kinesiology, body movement, biology, health promotions, etc. I have worked with physical therapist, cardiologist, and exercise physiologists, that value my opinion and we work together as a team.

By William Meyers, Thursday, December 15, 2011
Welding clamps?!?! For safty collars?! . . . Not to mention the bad form, they didnt even know how to put the weight on correctly!

Close
  • Please login to submit feedback!
Close